Nominee CJ Sharma rejects seniority rule, defends merit-based appointment

KATHMANDU: Proposed Chief Justice Dr. Manoj Kumar Sharma has defended his nomination, stating that his selection was based on merit and competence rather than seniority, during a parliamentary hearing on his appointment.

Responding to questions before the Parliamentary Hearing Committee on Tuesday, Sharma argued that elevation to the post of Chief Justice should not be viewed as a routine promotion based on seniority.

“Appointment to the position of Chief Justice should not be treated as a promotion but as a constitutional appointment. Seniority does not appear to be a strong determining factor,” he said, adding that the recommendation process followed constitutional procedures through the Constitutional Council.

Sharma also responded to allegations referring to him as “nepo baby,” saying such labels were subjective and open to interpretation.

“I do not know how to interpret the term nepo baby. I was appointed as a judge in the appellate court based on my qualification and competence, completed my tenure, returned to legal practice after my constitutional term ended, and was later reappointed to the Supreme Court,” he said.

He further stated that public opinions on his background were personal perspectives and should not override his professional record.

“Anyone is free to form their own view. I believe my merit and competence speak for themselves. No legal or judicial principle disqualifies someone from appointment solely due to family relations,” Sharma added.