‘Smile 2’ delivers psychological horror with a haunting performance by Naomi Scott

KATHMANDU: The much-anticipated sequel to 2022’s psychological horror hit, Smile 2, was released already on Oct 18, 2024, bringing with it a chilling exploration of trauma, fame, and supernatural terror.

Directed by Parker Finn, the film follows Skye Riley, a celebrated pop star played by Naomi Scott, who finds herself tormented by an eerie and relentless force as she prepares for a high-profile tour.

With its unnerving atmosphere and psychological depth, Smile 2 cements its place in the horror genre, offering both thrills and introspection.

Critics Praise Its Horror Elements and Scott’s Performance

Smile 2 has received generally positive reviews, with critics lauding its terrifying sequences and Scott’s powerful portrayal of a woman unraveling under supernatural and personal pressures. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an 86% approval rating based on 201 reviews, with an average score of 6.7/10.

The critical consensus highlights the film’s strong performances and well-executed horror elements, though some reviewers note its predictability.

Metacritic reports a weighted average score of 67 out of 100, reflecting “generally favorable reviews.” While the film doesn’t stray too far from the formula of its predecessor, it effectively builds upon its psychological themes, ensuring a disturbing yet engaging experience.

Box Office Success

Proving the enduring appeal of psychological horror, Smile 2 has seen impressive commercial success, grossing $138.1 million worldwide against a modest $28 million budget. Its opening weekend alone raked in $23 million, slightly surpassing the first film’s debut.

The numbers solidify the franchise’s viability and confirm audience interest in its chilling narrative.

Audience Reception: Mixed to Positive

Viewers have responded with a mix of enthusiasm and critique. CinemaScore reports an average grade of “B,” an improvement from the original’s “B–,” indicating a more favorable reception. PostTrak surveys show a 71% overall positive score, with many praising the film’s horror sequences and Naomi Scott’s gripping performance.

Notable Reviews

• /Film: Hailed Smile 2 for its relentless horror and Scott’s performance, stating, “Scott is wrung through the wringer, and we’re with her every step of the way, watching as her sanity snaps and she grapples with both supernatural horrors and her own inner loathing.”
• AP News: Commended the film’s satirical take on pop star fame, noting, “Finn’s use of humor, jump-scares, and gross-out tricks, along with Scott’s compelling performance, anchors the movie.”
• Vulture: Offered a more critical view, arguing, “As Skye becomes increasingly unable to tell what’s actually happening and what’s a waking nightmare, we should feel more for her. Instead, we lose interest, as the whole thing becomes pointless and even a little cynical and cruel.”

Final Verdict: A Haunting and Visually Striking Sequel

Smile 2 builds upon its predecessor’s foundation with a darker, more intense look into the psychological horrors of trauma and fame.

While some criticisms highlight pacing issues and familiar tropes, the film largely succeeds in delivering an unsettling and compelling experience.

Naomi Scott’s performance is a standout, anchoring the film with raw emotion and intensity.

For horror enthusiasts, Smile 2 is a worthy follow-up that keeps the terror alive and well.

Trailer:

Final Trailer:

[The review was conducted independently and with assistance from agencies.]